Northern Temper · Paper No. 03

Common Barrel

Canada ships its crude south to be refined, then buys fuel back. Here is a proposal to own the refinery instead, together.

In brief

  • Nearly nine barrels in ten of the crude Canada exports go to the United States to be refined. Then Canada buys fuel back.
  • The skeptics are right about one thing. Alberta’s last new refinery was estimated at $5.7 billion and finished above $10 billion. So the question is not whether to refine more at home. It is who owns the refinery, and how it gets built.
  • Prairie farmers answered the same squeeze in 1935 with a refinery they still own. It runs 130,000 barrels a day, and nobody can buy it out from under them.
  • The money is already looking for Canadian projects: a $25 billion federal fund, a $50 billion pension fund, and more. None of it is earmarked for refining.
  • Common Barrel is one refinery, held in a partnership, owned in layers: producers through a co-op with one vote each, pension funds paid by contract, First Nations as owners from day one, the Canada Strong Fund on the same terms as everyone, lenders paid first.
  • It is not a coin, not an offer, and not finished. The ask is scrutiny, from the people who would have to make it work.

How to read this

Every figure here is public, dated and sourced in the receipts at the end. The structure is a proposal, not a prospectus; nothing in it is for sale.

It is written for the people it would need: refinery builders, producers, pension investment committees, people in government, the leaders of a Nation’s development corporation, and any Canadian who would want a share. Where a term of art appears, the words used here explain it in plain language.

One · The round trip We ship the barrel south. We buy the fuel back.

The round tripCrude from the oil sands travels south across the border to refineries in the United States, and fuel travels back north to Canadian pumps. The refineries are the one part of the trip Canada does not own.CANADAUNITED STATESOIL SANDScrudeCANADIAN PUMPSfuelU.S. REFINERIESnot ourscrude, southfuel, north
Figure 1 · The round trip. Nearly nine barrels in ten of the crude Canada exports go to the United States to be refined, and Canada still buys refined products from American suppliers.1

On October 19, Albertans voted on whether to start down the road to leaving Canada.2 Two weeks before that, Quebec elected a Parti Québécois government that has promised a referendum of its own, though not before 2029.3

Six weeks before the vote, a pollster asked Albertans leaning toward the separation option what was driving them. Only 26 per cent named independence.4

The rest had other reasons. I read that as people sending a message, and I think the message deserves a better answer than a slogan. Here is mine.

Two · The case against The skeptics have a point.

Let me start with the strongest argument against what I’m about to propose, because it’s a good one.

When B.C.’s premier floated a new Canadian refinery in January, a UBC business lecturer called it “not an economically justifiable or feasible idea.”5

Alberta’s last new refinery is the best evidence for his side. Sturgeon was estimated at $5.7 billion when it was approved in 2012. It finished at more than $10 billion, for a plant that processes roughly 78,000 barrels a day.6, 7, 8

$5.7B
Estimate when approved, 2012.6
Over $10B
Final cost, Alberta’s Sturgeon refinery.7, 8

If we build a refinery the way that one was built, the skeptics will be right. So the real question isn’t whether Canada should refine more of its own oil. It’s who should own the refinery, and how it gets built.

Three · The farmers’ answer Farmers solved this once.

In 1933, Ottawa put a tariff of 3.7 cents a gallon on American gasoline, and the small prairie fuel co-ops lost their cheap supply. They could also see the big oil companies moving the profit into refining, where the co-ops had no seat.9

So that winter, they started a drive to build their own refinery.

Figure 2 · The Co-op refinery, from a tariff to today
  1. 1933

    The squeeze

    A new tariff cuts prairie fuel co-ops off from cheap American gasoline.9

  2. 1935

    The answer

    In the refinery’s own telling, eight farmers get it started in Regina.10

  3. 130,000

    Barrels a day, today

    More than 1,000 people work there. It is owned through Federated Co-operatives by about 160 local co-ops.11, 12

Nobody got rich flipping shares in it. That was never the point. The people who use it own it, and nobody else can buy it out from under them.

Four · What changed The money is already looking.

The farmers had to raise every dollar themselves. We don’t.

In April, Ottawa launched the Canada Strong Fund, a $25 billion sovereign wealth fund that invests alongside private capital on equal terms. It plans a retail product so any Canadian can put in savings, with the initial capital protected. The details are still being designed.13, 14

Canada’s big pension funds are bringing money home too.

Commitment Billions of dollars
Maple Fund, CPP Investments and Brookfield, five years $50B
Canada Strong Fund, federal, three years $25B
Ontario Teachers’, by the end of 2027 $10B
OMERS, at least, over five years $10B
Figure 3 · Commitments announced in 2026 for Canadian investment. Time frames differ, and none of it is earmarked for refining.13, 15, 16, 17

The money is looking for projects. The question is who ends up owning them.

Five · The structure Owned in layers.

Here is the structure I’m proposing. I call it Common Barrel: one refinery, held in a partnership, owned in layers.

Who owns Common BarrelFour owners hold equity in the Common Barrel partnership: a producers’ co-op with one vote per member, pension funds paid by contract, First Nations as owners from day one, and the Canada Strong Fund on the same terms as all. Lenders provide debt, shown as a dashed line, and are paid first. The partnership owns the refinery.PRODUCERS’ CO-OPone vote per memberPENSION FUNDSpaid by contractFIRST NATIONSowners from day oneCANADA STRONG FUNDsame terms as allLENDERSdebt, paid firstownlendCOMMON BARRELthe partnershipTHE REFINERYCanadian-owned
Figure 4 · Who owns Common Barrel. Solid lines are ownership. The dashed line is debt, which is repaid before anyone else is paid.

Producers join through a co-op. They buy in by the barrel they commit, get paid by the barrel they deliver, and get one vote each. Saskatchewan already has a law for exactly this kind of co-op, and under that model members’ own money typically covers 35 to 50 per cent of start-up costs.18, 19

How a barrel becomes a shareFour steps in a row: a producer commits barrels, buys in with one share per barrel committed, delivers the barrels, and is paid per barrel delivered. Underneath all four, one rule: one vote per member, however many barrels.COMMITbarrels a yearBUY INone share eachDELIVERat the gateGET PAIDby the barrelONE VOTE PER MEMBERhowever many barrels
Figure 5 · How a barrel becomes a share. Pay and payment follow the barrels; the vote does not.

Pension funds come in as partners, paid through processing fees set by contract instead of bets on fuel prices. Pension funds favour infrastructure because it pays returns that keep pace with inflation.20

First Nations hold equity as owners from the start, on terms they set with us rather than terms written for them.

The Canada Strong Fund takes a stake on the same terms as everyone else. Any Canadian who buys its retail product would own a slice.

Lenders get paid first. Everyone else gets paid in a set order, written down before construction starts.

Each party, in one row

Figure 6 · What each party puts in, what it gets back, and what it decides. Drawn only from the structure above.
Party Puts in Gets back Decides
Producers’ co-op Barrels committed, bought in by the barrel Payment by the barrel delivered One vote each, and any sale of the refinery
Pension funds Long-term capital, as partners Processing fees set by contract, not bets on fuel prices A partner’s say
First Nations Equity from day one An owner’s share Terms they set with us
Canada Strong Fund A stake on the same terms as everyone else The same return as everyone else, shared with any Canadian in its retail product The same say as any other partner
Lenders Debt Paid first, before anyone else No ownership

Six · Control Nobody can buy control.

In an ordinary company, votes follow money. Whoever owns the most shares runs it, and can sell it.

Votes in a company versus a co-opOn the left, an ordinary company: one large investor outvotes four small ones. On the right, a co-op: five members each hold one equal vote.ORDINARY COMPANYvotes follow moneyone investor outvotes the restCO-OPone member, one voteno one can buy control
Figure 7 · Votes in a company versus a co-op.

In a co-op, every member gets one vote no matter how much they put in. A big producer is paid in proportion to its barrels, but it can’t take over. Under Common Barrel, selling the refinery would need the producers’ co-op to agree.

Seven · Payment Proof before payment.

One modern piece belongs in this. When a producer’s crude crosses the meter at the refinery gate, three records already exist: the meter’s reading, the pipeline’s ticket, and an independent inspector’s report.

Put those records on a shared ledger and payment follows automatically when two of the three agree. If one disagrees, the payment waits for a person to look.

Proof before paymentThree records, the gate meter, the pipeline ticket and the inspector’s report, feed one question: do two of three agree? If yes, payment is released to the producer. If no, the payment waits while a person reviews it.GATE METERvolumePIPELINEbatch ticketINSPECTORquality report2 OF 3 AGREE?the ledger checksyesnoPAYMENT RELEASEDto the producerPAYMENT WAITSa person reviews it
Figure 8 · Proof before payment. The machine pays when the records agree; a person decides when they do not.

Canada has already tested the plumbing. In March 2026, Export Development Canada issued the country’s first tokenized bond, with regulators’ approval, on a private network.21 The contracts stay in charge. Canadian banks still move the money. A person can always press pause.

Eight · The limits What this isn’t.

It isn’t a coin.
Venezuela launched a token backed by its oil in 2018 and shut it down in January 2024.22
It isn’t an offer.
Nobody can invest in Common Barrel today, and I’m not asking anyone to.
It isn’t finished.
Refining margins swing. Construction budgets blow up. The skeptics have a point, and this plan has to answer them in numbers before anyone pours concrete.

Nine · The precedent Alberta and Quebec have done this before.

In 1962, Jean Lesage called an election on a single idea: buy out Quebec’s private power companies and fold them into Hydro-Québec. His slogan was maîtres chez nous, masters in our own house. He won, and Hydro-Québec became a source of pride.23, 24

In 1976, Peter Lougheed set up the Heritage Savings Trust Fund to put 30 per cent of Alberta’s resource revenue into savings.25

Both provinces already understand the idea underneath Common Barrel. My view: when you own the asset, you stop asking for permission.

Each province alone is a vassal. Together we are a peer.

Ten · The ask Not money. Scrutiny.

If you build refineries, run a producer, sit on a pension investment committee, work in government, or help lead a Nation’s development corporation, tell me what breaks first.

If you’re a Canadian who would want a share of a refinery this country owns, say so, loudly enough for Ottawa to hear it.

Strong. Proud. Free.

Jesse James

Common Barrel is a proposal for public discussion. It is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any security. A French edition is in preparation.

Words used here Six terms, plainly.

Co-op
A business owned by the people who use it. Every member has one vote, however much they put in, and the surplus goes back to members in proportion to their use.
New Generation Co-operative
A Saskatchewan form of co-op for processing what members produce. A share comes with the right, and the duty, to deliver a set amount each year, so the plant knows its supply before it is built.18, 19
Sovereign wealth fund
A pool of public money a government invests for the long run rather than spends. The Canada Strong Fund is Canada’s first at the federal level.13
Processing fee
A set payment per barrel for turning crude into fuel, agreed by contract. The refinery earns it whatever the pump price does, which is why a pension fund can hold the asset without betting on oil.
Equity and debt
Equity is ownership: it votes, and it is paid last. Debt is a loan: it does not vote, and it is paid first. The solid and dashed lines in Figure 4 are the two.
Shared ledger
One record of every barrel that each party can read and none can quietly change. Export Development Canada’s tokenized bond was Canada’s test of the same plumbing, under the regulators’ eye.21

Receipts Every figure, sourced.

  1. CTV News, "Eby says Canada should build refineries, not pipelines," January 6, 2026, citing Canada Energy Regulator data. ctvnews.ca. The share is from the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers, Canadian Exports of Crude Oil and Natural Gas, April 17, 2026, from Canada Energy Regulator and U.S. Energy Information Administration data: the United States took 87 per cent of Canada's crude exports in 2025, down from 95 per cent in 2023. capp.ca
  2. CBC News, guide to the 10 questions in Alberta's October 19 referendum. cbc.ca
  3. Al Jazeera, "Secessionist Parti Québécois wins Quebec election," October 6, 2026. aljazeera.com
  4. CBC News, on an Abacus Data survey of 1,000 Albertans, September 4 to 7, 2026. cbc.ca
  5. CBC News, "B.C. premier proposes publicly funded refinery over pipeline," January 2026. cbc.ca
  6. Oil & Gas Journal, "Rising costs delay Alberta refinery project," December 5, 2013. ogj.com
  7. CBC News, "Sturgeon Refinery saga." cbc.ca
  8. CBC News, "Alberta taxpayers could be on hook for $26B oil refinery." cbc.ca
  9. Wikipedia, "CCRL Refinery Complex," on the 1933 tariff of 3.7 cents a gallon and the eight farmers whose money started the refinery. Federated Co-operatives' own history page, "The story of the Co-op Refinery Complex" (June 9, 2015), was the paper's source and no longer resolves. wikipedia.org
  10. Co-op Refinery Complex, company description on LinkedIn. linkedin.com
  11. CKOM, "Co-op Refinery celebrates 90 years of operation," June 27, 2025. ckom.com
  12. Wikipedia, "Federated Co-operatives." wikipedia.org
  13. Government of Canada, Department of Finance, Canada Strong Fund backgrounder, April 27, 2026. canada.ca
  14. McMillan LLP, "Canada Launches Its First National Sovereign Wealth Fund." mcmillan.ca
  15. The Canadian Press via Advisor.ca, "CPP Investments, Brookfield launch $50B fund," September 15, 2026. advisor.ca
  16. Benefits and Pensions Monitor, "Pension funds put nearly $100 billion back on home ice," September 16, 2026. benefitsandpensionsmonitor.com
  17. Benefits and Pensions Monitor, OMERS first-half 2026 results. benefitsandpensionsmonitor.com
  18. Information Services Corporation of Saskatchewan, The New Generation Co-operatives Act. isc.ca
  19. Encyclopedia of Saskatchewan, "New Generation Co-operative Model." esask.uregina.ca
  20. Luciano Arvin, "Bring Canada's pension funds back home to build our own economy," Policy Options, December 1, 2025. policyoptions.irpp.org
  21. Export Development Canada, "EDC issues Canada's first tokenized bond," March 5, 2026. The Ontario Securities Commission, the Autorité des marchés financiers and the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization approved the project the same week. edc.ca
  22. Wikipedia, "Petro (token)." wikipedia.org
  23. The Canadian Encyclopedia, "Jean Lesage." thecanadianencyclopedia.ca
  24. The Canadian Encyclopedia, "Quiet Revolution." thecanadianencyclopedia.ca
  25. Wikipedia, "Alberta Heritage Savings Trust Fund" (founded 19 May 1976 under Peter Lougheed; 30 per cent of non-renewable resource revenue deposited until 1983), and Government of Alberta, "Heritage Savings Trust Fund." The CTV Edmonton story the paper cited now returns a 404. wikipedia.org · alberta.ca

A note on this edition. Two of the paper's source links had died before it was published here and were replaced with sources that state the same facts; the export share was corrected to the current Canada Energy Regulator figure. The page's own record of what changed is in its source.

Pass it on

This only works if it travels.

Everything here is public domain. Copy it, quote it in full, post it without a link back. Nothing is asked in return.

Ready to post — tap to copy